Prev Blog
<<

Pitfalls of lease options

Next Blog
>>
thefullpriceofferguys Category: Buy & Hold
Total Views: 737
Member Comments: 4
Posted on: 10/20/2008
Posted by: thefullpriceofferguys
Blog Points: 26
View all blogs >>
PITFALLS OF LEASE OPTIONS

     SELLER-SIDE:

1.     A Lease Option violates the Lenders Due-On-Sale Clause.
      (The Lender CAN call the Loan Due in full within 60 days.)

2.     The Tenant has a claim of Equitable Interest in the Property.

3.     The Tenants Judgment Creditors CAN attach a lien on the Seller's Property.

4.     Only 14% of all Optionees ever exercise their Option (purchase the house).

5.     Damages.

6.     The Seller can't evict a non-paying Tenant/Buyer, they must FORECLOSE.

7.     Negative Cash Flow.

8.     More Risk and Liability.

9.     No Asset Protection.

10.     Since 1917 the IRS ruled that there is NO SUCH THING as a Lease Option.  (It is a DISGUISED "SALE", period.)

11.     The Property can be reassessed for tax purposes.

12.     Loss of 1031 Exchange Privileges.

     BUYER-SIDE

1.     The owner POCKETS RENT and does not make payment – FORECLOSURE.

2.     The owner GETS DIVORCED, house must be SOLD as part of settlement.

3.     The owner files for BANKRUPTCY and MUST SELL all assets.

4.     The owner GETS SUED and a judgment is placed on home or is FORCED TO SELL.

5.     The DOS may be called in.

6.     If a DEATH takes place, property could get tied up in PROBATE.

7.     The buyer may make improvements to home only to lose them for any of the above reasons.

8.     The buyer may never be able to use the rent credits in an Rent to own type of Lease Option.

9.     The buyer may never get to the point of being financed (only 14% do).

10.     The buyer will, more than likely, LOSE THE OPTION MONEY.

11.     The buyer can not get the TAX ADVANTAGES.

12.     The buyer can not share in any FUTURE APRECIATION of the property.
Vieving 1 - 4 out of 4 comments
thefullpriceofferguys

Posted By: thefullpriceofferguys on 10/21/2008
One of my advisers who did 60+ lease options finally got nailed by an Arizona judge based on a few of those bullet points I've mentioned above.  The lease contract and option contract were separate and the judge still nailed him on those.  Defaulting tenant was claiming equitable interest in real property and the judge ruled against the lease option investor.  I'm looking for that actual PDF file that he gave me.  It also has precedent court cases to support it as well.  He stopped using the old lease option strategy that was taught by the guru's and now uses land trusts to simulate lease options instead.

I agree with RealEstateInvestor that there is a way to do lease options safely but just be aware of these potential risks and pitfalls.  The best anyone can do is to get a competent attorney to review your contracts and mitigate those risks. 

BTW, I've accepted the debate and I will be going over how to simulate lease options using title holding land trusts.
 
bswope

Posted By: bswope on 10/21/2008
Another option that I have used in the past is a purchase contract with a  delayed closing.  The buyer gives you "X' amount for a down payment and pays "X" amount monthly.  They have a vested interest because of the down stroke and are less likely to skip than if you give them so much credited from their rent per month towards the purchase.
 
Real Estate Investor
EducatorAmbassador
Posted By: Real Estate Investor on 10/21/2008
You have no idea what you are talking about!

I would love to debate you on each and every point you try and make here. None of them are valid. If You do a lease option contract correctly you avoid every issue you try and make above.

Im glad only 26 people have wasted their time reading this negative crap.

Sean
 
Chad

Posted By: Chad on 10/21/2008

One way to fix all this is to have a 12 Month Rental Agreement and an Option to Purchase Agreement. We keep the 2 seperate and the Option to Purchase spells out that they have no equity position in the property. I had to do an eviction and had no problem.

http://www.StressFreeLandlord.com